Softshell vs Hardshell Jacket for Hiking: Which Shell Suits Your Trails?
- Primary Signal: Softshell vs Hardshell Jacket for Hiking: Which Shell Suits Your Trails?
- Overview: Softshell and hardshell jackets both claim to protect you from the weather, but they do opposite jobs. This guide compares waterproofing, breathability, weight and cost, and tells ...
- Verification: Analyzed and compiled by SkyFree Outfitters editorial monitoring desk.
Softshell and hardshell jackets both claim to protect you from the weather, but they do opposite jobs. This guide compares waterproofing, breathability, weight and cost, and tells you which shell to carry for which kind of hike.
This guide covers what a hardshell actually does, what a softshell actually does, which shell for which hike, and weight, cost and care. Each section explains the topic with concrete examples, so you can use what you learn straight away.
A hardshell is a fully waterproof jacket, usually rated at 20,000 mm or more, with taped seams that keep rain out even in hours of steady downpour. Hardshells use a waterproof membrane such as Gore-Tex or a similar 2.5- or 3-layer fabric, which blocks liquid water while letting some sweat vapour escape. The trade-off is breathability: even the best hardshell feels clammy on a steep climb, because no membrane moves sweat as fast as your body produces it.
A softshell is a stretchy, breathable jacket with a water-repellent finish that sheds light rain and wind but will soak through in sustained rain. Softshells breathe far better than hardshells, which makes them the better choice for active hiking in dry, windy or lightly drizzly conditions. Most softshells also stretch with your movement and feel far more comfortable as an everyday outer layer, which is why many hikers wear them all day.
Carry a hardshell when the forecast promises hours of rain, when you will be above treeline, or when a wet, cold day could become a safety problem. Carry a softshell for dry, windy ridges, for shoulder-season hiking with mixed weather, and for any trip where you will be moving fast and sweating hard. Many experienced hikers carry both on multi-day trips: the softshell as the daily outer layer and a featherweight hardshell, under 7 ounces, stuffed in the pack for real rain.
A good ultralight hardshell weighs 6 to 7 ounces and packs to the size of a fist, while a softshell is usually heavier at 10 to 14 ounces. Hardshells cost more, often 200 to 400 dollars for a good one, while softshells are usually cheaper and tougher against rock and brush. Both need their water-repellent finish renewed: wash with a technical cleaner and re-apply DWR treatment when water stops beading on the surface.